The Good, Bad And Ugly From The Green Bay Packers’ Win Over The Pittsburgh Steelers

There was no revenge.

Only more proof that Green Bay’s decision to pull the plug on Aaron Rodgers-era was the right one.

The Packers played their best half of the season Sunday night, outscoring host Pittsburgh, 28-9, in the second half and rallying for a 35-25 win over the host Steelers.

Green Bay played a miserable first half and trailed, 16-7, at the break. But the Packers scored on their first five second half possessions and pulled away from the Steelers.

The 41-year-old Rodgers, who spent 18 years in Green Bay before the Packers traded him on April 26, 2023, looked mediocre, at best. Rodgers threw for 219 yards and two touchdowns, but was sacked three times and spent most of the night throwing short passes and checkdowns.

Meanwhile, Jordan Love — the man who replaced Rodgers in Green Bay — was sensational throwing for 360 yards and three touchdowns.

The Packers improved to 5-1-1 and are the NFC’s No. 1 seed. Pittsburgh lost its second straight game and fell to 4-3.

Here’s the ‘Good, Bad and Ugly’ from the Packers’ win.

THE GOOD

TUCKER KRAFT: The Packers’ standout tight end won’t be a free agent until after the 2026 season. The sooner Green Bay can get him locked up, though, the better.

Kraft continued his breakout season with seven receptions for 143 yards and two touchdowns on national Tight Ends Day.

Kraft had a 16-yard touchdown reception in the first quarter where he caught a pass in the right flat, got a head of steam and ran through four Steelers on his way to the endzone.

“The more things that he continues to do, the more he just pours into it,” Packers tight ends coach John Dunn said of Kraft. “He wants to be as good as he can possibly be in every area. So that part is fun to see.”

With Green Bay’s offense stuck in first gear early in the third quarter, Kraft had the most improbable 59-yard reception you’ll ever see.

Love was under duress and threw a prayer up for Kraft. Somehow Kraft caught the ball 15 yards downfield, fought off a defender, then rumbled 59 yards to the Pittsburgh 26. Six players later, Love hit Savion Williams for an 8-yard touchdown that pulled the Packers within 16-14.

Kraft had a terrific block on defensive end T.J. Watt that sprung Emanuel Wilson for a 15-yard run.

Then Kraft found the endzone for the second time early in the fourth quarter, this time a 24-yard TD that pushed Green Bay’s lead to 29-19. Kraft beat his man to the inside, then angled to his left and ran away from two defenders for another score.

“I think ultimately it comes down to the work that he’s put in,” Packers quarterback Matt LaFleur said. “And then certainly he’s gone on the field and played at a high level. He’s just a guy that you can always count on to do the right thing.”

JORDAN LOVE: The Packers quarterback had one of the best games of his young career. Love completed 29-of-37 passes for 360 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions for a passer rating of 134.2.

Love completed 20 straight passes at one point, the longest streak by a Green Bay quarterback since Brett Favre in 2007.

“I would say one of his superpowers is his ability to stay composed in the most chaotic of moments,” LaFleur said of Love. “And I think that’s true with most great quarterbacks is they just are going to stay even keel and play the next play and treat it as its own entity. And I think he has done a really nice job with that.”

CHRISTIAN WATSON: Welcome back Christian Watson.

The Packers wide receiver suffered a torn ACL in Week 18, 2024.

Watson made his season debut Sunday and caught four passes for 85 yards, including a 33-yard reception.

“He’s a rare breed in the fact that he can take the top off,” LaFleur said. “And I also think he’s got some goon type qualities at the same time in regards to being able to be very physical in the run game.

“So I just think what he brings size, speed element and his, it just gives us so much flexibility as an offense, because you can plug and play him in any position, and you can do it within a game, you know, within a series. And he just doesn’t blink at it. And there’s very few guys that I know that can go in and play the X, the Y or the X, the F or the Z.”

SENSATIONAL SECOND HALF: The Packers had a dreadful first half and trailed, 16-7, at the break.

But Green Bay scored touchdowns on its first three drives of the second half to take control.

Those drives were nine plays and 90 yards, 10 plays and 78 yards, and four plays for 45 yards. That’s a total of 23 plays for 213 yards — an average of 9.3 yards per play.

The Packers then added field goals on their next two possessions, giving them 28 points on their first five second half drives.

CARRINGTON VALENTINE: After playing just two snaps last week, Valentine replaced Nate Hobbs at outside corner and shined.

Early in the second quarter, the Steelers had a third-and-3 on Green Bay’s 32 and Valentine was left 1-on-1 with Pittsburgh standout wideout D.K. Metcalf. Rodgers threw deep for Metcalf, who had inside position, but Valentine stripped loose what would have been a 32-yard touchdown.

Valentine made an aggressive and legal tackle on Pat Freiermuth that sent the tight end to the blue medical tent.

THIS AND THAT: Edgerrin Cooper forced a fourth quarter fumble that Javon Bullard recovered. … The Packers rotated Jordan Morgan and Sean Rhyan at right guard. Those two had split time early in the season, but Morgan played 100% of the snaps last week at Arizona. … Rashan Gary had two sacks of Rodgers and Micah Parsons had one. … Kingsley Enagbare dumped Jaylen Warren for a 5-yard loss midway through the second quarter. … Green Bay held Pittsburgh to 1-of-10 on third downs. … Love was not sacked.

THE BAD

BRANDON MCMANUS: Green Bay’s kicker missed the last two weeks with a right quadriceps injury and was questionable this week. McManus should have probably taken a third week off.

McManus went through a pre-game workout and the Packers deemed him healthy enough to play. McManus then went 2-for-4 on field goals.

McManus can be forgiven for missing a 57-yard field goal, one that was dead center but 2 yards short. But there was no excuse for him pulling a 44-yarder wide left on the final play of the first half.

McManus did rebound to make a pair of second half field goals.

With McManus out, Lucas Havrisik made all four of his field goals and all six of his extra points. Havrisik also set a new franchise record with a 61-yard field goal in Arizona last week.

McManus has enough house credit built up that his job is almost certainly safe. But the fact the Packers haven’t released Havrisik tells you they might not be “all in” on McManus.

RUN DEFENSE: The Steelers lined up with multiple tight ends, extra offensive linemen and wide receivers that are terrific blockers. Then they had 77 rushing yards in the first half.

Green Bay clamped down in the second half, though, allowing just 16 rushing yards after intermission.

THIS AND THAT: Green Bay reserve running back Chris Brooks had a holding penalty on the opening kickoff. … Javon Bullard had a holding penalty on Pittsburgh’s first punt of the second half.

THE UGLY

KEISEAN NIXON: Ahmad Carroll. Kevin King. Estus Hood.

The Packers have had their share of miserable performances by lousy cornerbacks through the year.

You can throw Nixon’s name into that mix.

Everything Nixon touched on this night turned to nonsense.

The Packers’ cornerback took his first stab at returning punts this season. It failed miserably.

Nixon was nonchalant while trying to Corliss Waitman’s punt and dropped it. Fortunately for the Packers, heady Zayne Anderson was Johnny on the spot and recovered the fumble.

Nixon also allowed a 45-yard reception to Roman Wilson on Pittsburgh’s opening drive that led to a Chris Boswell field goal. Nixon was also flagged for defensive holding when the Packers appeared to have the Steelers stopped midway through the second quarter.

Late in the second quarter, the Steelers had a third-and-9 at Green Bay’s 36 when Nixon was flagged 21 yards for pass interference to keep the drive alive. Three plays later, Metcalf beat Nixon for a 2-yard TD and Pittsburgh led, 16-7, at halftime.

Nixon was better in the second half, but his first half will make things uncomfortable in the film room this week.