Exposed: Probe finds ICE wrongly detained staggering 2,300 people in just 6 months

In yet another display of the Trump administration’s disregard for the US Constitution, there have been at least 2,300 cases in which federal judges have ruled that immigration officials illegally detained people without bond or due process since just July, according to one journalist.

Politico reporter Kyle Cheney shared some of the cases he’s tracked in a thread on the social media platform X late Saturday. “This is one that stands out,” he said of Sonik Manaserian, an Iranian woman of Armenian ethnicity who is a member of the Baha’i faith.

According to an order out of the Central District of California in Manaserian’s case, US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) “arrested a chronically ill, 70-year-old woman, who came to this country to avoid religious persecution and applied for asylum, who has lived here peacefully for 26 years and complied with all check-in requirements and other conditions of release, who has no known criminal record and poses no threat to anyone, without notice or the process required by their own regulations and without any plan for removing her from this country, then kept her in detention for months without sufficient medical care—and they do not have any argument to offer to even try to justify these actions.”

Cheney’s thread came just hours after Customs and Border Protection (CBP) fatally shot legal observer and nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis, less than three weeks after ICE officer Jonathan Ross similarly killed Renee Good in Minnesota’s largest city.

“Minnesota courts have been inundated with these cases since the beginning of Operation Metro Surge last month,” said the journalist, noting a Friday order in which a judge freed Audberto J., a Mexican man residing in the state, “where he and his wife have lived and raised three children together over the last 20 years.”

While the Trump administration has repeatedly claimed that its immigration enforcement operations are targeting “the worst of the worst,” like the vast majority of immigrants actually seized by agents with the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in recent months, Audberto J. has no criminal history, according to the order.

“Yet another ruling from Friday, freeing a man detained by ICE in Minnesota who suffered severe head injuries during his arrest and has been hospitalized since. The man claims ICE has required him to be shackled in the hospital, against the wishes of doctors,” Cheney noted. “Here’s another Minnesota ruling that just came in tonight: A federal judge is threatening DHS with contempt for transferring a petitioner out of the state despite a court order enjoining the administration from doing so.”

The journalist added to the thread on Sunday, as judges in Minnesota continued issue to rulings. In one of those cases, “Judge [Katherine] Menendez—who issued last week’s injunction against ICE’s retaliatory use of pepper spray—just ordered the release of a Kenyan woman arrested while picking up seizure medication at CVS.”

Sharing the thread, American Immigration Council senior fellow Aaron Reichlin-Melnick stressed “this is what ‘mass deportations’ looks like. Neither due process nor basic humanity. Don’t look away.”

Immigrant Defenders Law Center co-founder and CEO Lindsay Toczylowski said that “as you read this excellent thread, let it sink in that one of the most pervasive issues for people in ICE detention is lack of access to counsel which means in most cases people have no shot at filing these challenges to their illegal detentions in federal court.”

The Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution states in part that no person shall “be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law,” and protects various rights in legal proceedings. The Trump administration has also faced intense criticism recently for its disregard of rights protected by the First, Second, and Fourth amendments.

Cheney was praised by other journalists for “such good shoe-leather reporting,” as “PBS NewsHour” correspondent Lisa Desjardins put it. Lawfare senior editor Roger Parloff suggested that he “should get a Pulitzer for this thread.”

John Yarmuth, a former newspaper editor and Democratic congressman from Kentucky, said that “this is a great example of a journalist doing his very critical job. Now it’s up to government officials to act to correct these injustices. AND be shamed and replaced if they don’t.”

Last Thursday, seven Democrats in the US House of Representatives voted with nearly all Republicans to pass a multibillion-dollar DHS funding bill. Pretti’s killing has increased pressure on all senators to reject it. While immigration agents’ deadly and illegal actions have fueled calls to “abolish ICE,” some lawmakers are demanding reforms at the agency and across the department.